Skip to main content

Trading Vintage Masters - What I didn't consider

Sad! I didn't hoard Power 9 two days ago. From 150, Black Lotus upsurged back to 270, other  P9 members have risen by 20% - 30%.

How do we explain this tragedy?
1. Bots are buying - they usually start making waves two weeks after release events, but this time, 2 days. Dominating bots set the prices in MTGO: when they all buy at 130, the price is 130, when they rise to 270, players must accept 270. They are lords in MTGO.

2. Players are buying - I noticed a significant difference in number of drafters between the weekends and the week days. Initially, it's a simple supply-demand difference that drove the prices up. But the price movement was amplified by the over reactions of bots.


Besides, bots are still not buying foils. Here are the reasons for their decision. First, their owners believe foils in Vintage Master are easier to open than in other sets(one foil per pack for Vintage Masters; one foil per 8 packs for other sets). Second, they consider foils as hard-to-sell stocks. The first reasons seems legitimate. I have seen all the cards opened by a streamer who cracked 116 packs before release events, I feel foils in VM are easier to find than in other sets. And the second reason made me think they are now overbuying the regulars and selling them to players immediately, in a way much like what we did to P9s. When the customers wanes dramatically some day, they will suddenly pull down the prices of regular cards. And when it happens, the loss will still be too small comparing with the profit they will have made from now on. For foils, Bots can't repeat the hoarding, selling, profit processes due to their poor liquidity. So, definitely, the prices buyers pay today for the foils are not the prices bots expect in the next one or two months. Not only should we be caution when buying regular cards, we must also pay as low as possible for the foils. In long term, foil dual lands and Force of Will are the cards I want to stock up. For quick profits and safety, I regularly flip the foils and P9s on hand.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is Magic Origins about?

If I am right, Magic Origins is a collection of "redesigned" old cards in MTG history. Evidence so far supports the prediction. We have: Dark Petition reminiscing Demonic Tutor, Day's Undoing replacing Timetwister, Honored Hierarch taking after Noble Hierarch. I believe more cards from Power Nine and old sets will appear in Standard but with lowered power level. Let's make some wild guess before the spoiler's out: 1. All ten Shock lands return ( Dual lands ) update: painlands, not shocklands 2. There are remakes for Armageddon, Nevinyrral's Disk and Wrath of God update: they remade Cataclysm. 3. Moxes will appear with 1 mana cost and "enter the battlefield tapped" 4. Something close to Force of Will is in the set

GWx Starfield of Nyx Deck

People say Magic Origins is a down-graded set. To me, It feels more like Ice Age then Khans in the variety of card functions and types. Of course, Ice Age was a fun deck, weakness never harms the entertaining level of cards. Starfield of Nyx  is an interesting one. It goes perfectly into enchantment decks evolved during late Theros Standard. Win conditions: 1. Bring Chromanticore into play from grave. 2. Attack with animated enchatments for winning. 3. Bring Whip of Erebos into play and reanimate Hornet Queen. 4. Bring Sigil of the Empty Throne into play 5. Assault Formation + high toughness creatures Removals: End Hostility Banishing Light     Doomwake Giant Defense: Nyx-Fleece Ram Courser of Kruphix Card Advantages: Ephara, God of the Polis Commune with the Gods Satyr Wayfinder Eidolon of Blossoms Gather the Pack Combos: Starfield of Nyx  + everything /  Font of Vigor Ephara, God...

The Return of Black Devotion

Many things happened this week. Tempest Remastered is announced; Nothing can I trust in old cards anymore. Rebound is confirmed as a mechanism in Dragons of Tarkir; I started to collect Monastery Mentor. I am also busy drafting Fate Khans Khans, during which I found a possible card for Black devotion: Ancestral Vengeance. In a draft, I didn't read clearly the text and put it on one of my creatures,without a choice, I put the +1/+1 on it too. I thought it add -1/-1 counter on another creature and make its target +1/+1. Whatever it does, I can put it on a creature for devotion.  The spoiled cards like Risen Executioner and Sidisi, Undead Vizier have given me some ideas of what a black devotion deck is like.    The deck may be like this one: Risen Executioner 4 Gray Merchant of Asphodel 4 a three drop zombie 4 Hero's Downfall 4 Ancestral Vengeance 4 Other removals 4-6 Palace Siege 2-4 Whip of Erebos 2 Thoughseize 4 a card drawin...